Livvy Dunne vs. Anastasia Ashley Who’d You Rather?! (Athletes In Black Bikinis Edition)

Livvy Dunne and Anastasia Ashley are painting the beaches black in their skimpiest bikinis … showing off in a pair of tiny black swimsuits — and, we gotta know the answer to the age-old question, Who’d You Rather?

These mouthwatering pics come from videos Livvy and Anastasia dropped on their respective social media accounts … with Livvy mouthing along to audio from the Pixar flick “Luca” before tossing herself into some crisp water.

Meanwhile, Anastasia stayed on dry land … posing on the balcony of some resort while Kodak Black‘s “Transportation” played over the clip.

Livvy and Anastasia really traded environments for their respective clips … ’cause Dunne’s used to performing on dry land for gymnastics — while Ashley’s got no issue splashing around in the waves as a pro surfer.